On the Front Page right now, Jerome is suggesting, that Obama is systematically losing the white vote. The problem is there is no data to back this up. Let's take a look at the CNN exits...
I've compiled a list of all states from Super Tuesday on which were primaries. I decided to take out Illinois and Arkansas, as both home states saw an obvious swing in a certain direction. I left New York in primarily because white voters in New York behaved very similarly to other states.
Alabama - 47% Clinton lead
Arizona - 15% Clinton lead
California - 1% Clinton lead
Connecticut - 1% Clinton lead
Delaware - 16% Clinton lead
Georgia - 10% Clinton lead
Massachusetts - 18% Clinton lead
Missouri - 18% Clinton lead
New Jersey - 24% Clinton lead
New York - 24% Clinton lead
Oklahoma - 14% Clinton lead (note, Edwards got 10% here)
Tennessee - 44% Clinton lead
Utah - 15% Obama lead
Louisiana - 28% Clinton lead
Maryland - 10% Clinton lead
Virginia - 5% Obama lead
Wisconsin - 9% Obama lead
Ohio - 30% Clinton lead
Rhode Island - 26% Clinton lead
Texas - 11% Clinton lead
Vermont - 22% Obama lead
Mississippi - 44% Clinton lead
Pennsylvania - 26% Clinton lead
North Carolina - 24% Clinton Lead
Indiana - 20% Clinton lead
Notice, Obama just won the white vote in primaries in four states, ultra-white Utah and Vermont, and Virginia and Wisconsin, when he was riding high in the nationwide zeitgeist.
Overall, the raw numbers show no shift except during his best period in late February. On super-Tuesday, he lost the white vote by 17.1% in the average contest. In late February, he lost it by 6%. In March, he lost it by 17.8%, and across PA, IN, and NC, the average has been 17.5%. Please note these numbers are just averages across contests, not weighted by population.
Anyway, grouping the states by type shows further that there has been no effective change
Southern:
AL - 47% Clinton
GA - 10% Clinton
OK - 14% Clinton (24% if Edwards is included)
TN - 41% Clinton
LA - 28% Clinton
MD - 10% Clinton
VA - 5% Obama
TX - 11% Clinton
MS - 44% Clinton
NC - 24% Clinton
Non-Southern:
CT - 1% Clinton
AZ - 15% Clinton
CA - 1% Clinton
DE - 16% Clinton
MA - 18% Clinton
MO - 18% Clinton
NJ - 24% Clinton
NY - 24% Clinton
UT - 15% Obama
WI - 9% Obama
OH - 30% Clinton
RI - 26% Clinton
VT - 22% Obama
PA - 26% Clinton
IN - 20% Clinton
I'm not going to sit down at this moment and do a regression analysis of each state, but there are only three clear trends: Obama tends to win the white vote in states with virtually no blacks (Arizona was the only exception), Obama did better than expected in is post super-Tuesday run-up, and Obama performs better with white voters in states which are wealthier and more educated.
That's all. His performance from Ohio on just isn't that different from his performance on Super Tuesday (at worst it maybe dropped by 4%-6%). No systematic collapse to be seen.
|
|
|
Permalink :: 38 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.